Hi friends! Remember last week when I talked about our summer foodie bucket list? Well the kids and I crossed off another item over the weekend when we made these No Churn OREO ice Cream Sandwiches. Not only were these bite-sized frozen treats unbelievably easy to make, but the homemade ice cream was truly outstanding. The kids have already made plans to try out some other flavor combinations, and really, we may think twice about buying store bought ice cream after this!
I’ve always thought it would be fun to make our own ice cream, but I didn’t want to go out and buy an ice cream maker. So then I started seeing tons of no churn ice cream recipes floating around, but still, I was skeptical.
But, my oldest has been doing her own research, and she kept bugging asking me to try making ice cream, so onto the bucket list it went. We tried one variation, but it didn’t turn out quite like we’d hoped, so we did a little experimenting and came up with a better version that pleased our picky palates.
This no churn ice cream recipe contains only three ingredients — how simple is that!
Ingredients
- 2 cups heavy cream
- 1 14-oz can sweetened condensed milk
- 12 OREO cookies, broken and crushed, plus extra whole cookies for making the sandwiches
Directions
To be honest, this is a messy job, but it’s oh so worth it! Since the cookies are small, we used a generous amount of ice cream to make the sandwiches. I like to smooth the ice cream out so that it looks nice and even, but since it’s so warm, the ice cream dribbled on the sides a little. Oh well — c’est la vie!
We made about 14 OREO ice cream sandwiches, which was enough for everyone to enjoy two of these frozen confections for dessert. The rest of the ice cream went back into the freezer, but I’m sure it won’t last very long!
I have to admit that I’m enjoying the kids’ summer foodie bucket list ideas probably as much as they are. I probably shouldn’t be, since I’m trying to keep the weight off, but it’s fun. And, I’m definitely glad that I let them talk me into making these no churn OREO ice cream sandwiches!
Thanks for visiting — have a super day!
You May Also Like
Lori Leigh says
Dee,
These look so delicious! And only 3 ingredients…you can't beat that. I don't think they would last long in our house 😉
Lori from LL Farm
Kristen Stevens says
These sound delicious and you made making your own ice cream sound easier then I expected so maybe I will have to give this a try. And The pictures make them look mouth watering! Add them to my craving list. Found from Treasure Box Tuesday.
Dee M says
Thanks, Kristen. I was surprised at how easy it is to make no churn ice cream, and it's definitely worth it! 🙂
Dee M says
The kids polished off the rest tonight, and I snuck a small taste! 😉
Ariel says
I just made home made no-churn ice cream this past weekend with a batch of brownies! It's so easy but SO perfect! I haven't tried making ice cream sandwiches yet though, and I love the Oreo idea. Thank you for sharing! 🙂
Dee M says
Brownie ice cream sounds wonderful! I'll have to tell the kids about this one.:)
Rue says
Oh wow, Dee…. these looks so good! I'm trying so hard not to eat a lot, but your blog recipes make it so difficult LOL
Have a great day 🙂
xo,
rue
Dee M says
Thanks, Rue — I blame it all on the kids! 😉
Storybook Apothecary says
this looks amazing! thanks for sharing – definitely gonna try it out ♥ have a wonderful 4th of July!
Carol says
I think I gained 5 pounds just looking at all this deliciousness, and I don't think I'll ever look at a Skinny Cow ice cream sandwich the same again! Have you tried the Lemon Oreos? They are wickedly good! Pair those with your homemade ice cream, & I think I might just swoon!
Big Rigs 'n Lil' Cookies says
I need these in my life! Stopping by from FoodieFriDIY
Trish Martin says
These looks so delicious. I wish I could grab one now.
Dee M says
I love lemon, and now I've got to try this! 🙂
Dee M says
You too! And I hope you enjoy the ice cream as much as we did. 🙂
Dee M says
These are the best! Thanks so much! 🙂
Dee M says
Thanks, Trish! They are so easy to make. 🙂
Leslie says
I've been thinking about cookies and cream ice cream all day! Hah, yum!
Erlene A says
I love that you can make this without an ice cream maker. We have one, but it take prep to freeze the bowl and I hate that…lol. Thanks for sharing on Merry Monday.
Miz Helen says
Wish I had one of your awesome Ice Cream Sandwiches right now. Thanks so much for sharing this awesome recipe with us at Full Plate Thursday!
Come Back Soon,
Miz Helen
Michelle Nahom says
I can pretty much guarantee that these would be a huge hit at our house! We have our little nephews and nieces visiting right now and I know they will love this! Pinning and sharing!
Cathy McInnes says
This looks beyond amazing!!! Thank you so much for sharing this on Making Memories Mondays! Hope to see you back Sun night 9PM EST! 🙂
Cathy